Browse Categories
 - Anchoring & Docking
 - Below Deck
 - Classic hardware
 - Clothing & Personal Gear
 - Charter
 - Electronics
 - Electrical
 - Engine Propulsion
 - Fishing
 - Maintenance
 - Magazines Media
 - Nautical Gifts
 - Navigation
 - On Deck
 - Safety Equipment
 - Small Craft
 - Sails & Rigging
 - Boating Education
 - Boating Websites

"How To" Articles

 Testimonials

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for our Email Newsletter
For Email Marketing you can trust

 


Product Recommendations

If you are a boater and have a piece of gear you recommend, please let us know.

"How To" Articles: above contain expanded information describing how many of these marine products work.

About MyBoatsGear.com

Contact Us

Site Map

Advertise with us

About us: MyBoatsGear.com is your buying guide for the latest and best boating equipment. Our independent reviews give you the honest look at products from the boaters perspective.

We provide reviews on the home page blog style with the latest on top---We know you do not have time to keep up with all the latest reviews, so we post all reviews in the 18 top-level categories and sub categories above.

Products reviews are available for access 24/7.

Site Copyright MyBoatsGear.com

 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



Lifejackets myths and truths



1 Which has more buoyancy foam or inflatable see USCG regs
2 Inherent buoyancy or inflatable See pros & cons
3 If you think just donning a lifejacket will save your life think again MAIB report of the sinking of Ouzo
4 Auto inflate lifejacket can inflate if it gets wet. This can be true, see auto inflator types below
5 How much buoyancy do I need. See Keep your chin above the water below
6 Carry an inflatable through airport security See FSA & Airline below
7 An inflatable counts as a lifejacket for USCG regs Not necessarily see USCG regs
8 Do I need a USCG approved lifejacket No, if the boat has the required 1 per person PFDs, your personal PFD is optional.
9 Should I use an auto inflate for dinghy sailing or watersports No, the auto inflate may go off when least needed.
10 Can Kids  wear auto inflates  Kids under 16 must wear a foam lifejacket
     

 



USCG regulations and lifejacket types


All recreational boats must carry one wearable lifejacket (Type I, II, III or Type V lifejacket) for each person aboard. A Type V lifejacket provides performance of either a Type I, II, or III lifejacket (as marked on its label) and must be used according to the label requirements.

Any boat 16ft and longer (except canoes and kayaks) must also carry one throwable lifejacket (Type IV lifejacket). An example of a type IV is throwable cushion. See below throwable flotation devices.


Link to USCGboating for full regulations

The table below shows USCG minimum buoyancy ratings for adults


Type Inherent buoyancy (e.g. foam) Inflatable  
Type I 22 lbs 34 lbs  
Type II 15.5 lbs 34lbs  
Type III 15.5 lbs 22.5 lbs  
Type IV 20 lbs    
Type V 15.5 - 22 lbs 22.5-34 lbs  

Notice the inflatable has more buoyancy than the inherent buoyancy lifejacket

An inflatable does not count toward a boat 1 lifejacket per person if its a type V.


Foam or inflatable

These are the three most popular models of PFD that you will find in a marine store

pfd type 1 This is a USCG type 1 lifejacket. This is the type that you buy to conform to the USCG regulations, but never wear. When you put one of these on they restrict movement and visibility. The upside is if the boat sinks, you can grab one of these and it will keep you afloat and head up.  
pfd auto inflate Inflatables are Type V by default, but some are approved for type II or III.

Auto inflates are good for powerboats keel boats where the deck is we above the water, in case of accidental inflation.

Some inflatables have more buoyancy than foam types. Some have the ability to keep your head up and options like leg straps, spray hood strobe light etc.

Auto inflates have buoyancy ratings from

The auto inflate is easier and more comfortable to wear than a type 1.

 
pfd buoyancy aid Type III PFD.

They come is various models to support, dinghy sailors, PWC riders, Kayakers, water skiers etc.

Often referred to as a buoyancy aid, as they will not totally support the wearer.
 

 

Lifejackets that have USCG approval are fitted with this label. Here you will see that this buoyancy aid is a type III Adult 40-44 inch chest.

pfd label

 

MAIB

The MAIB report is the investigation on the sinking of the 25ft yacht ouzo in the UK. Three of the crew drowned despite wearing lifejackets. The report looks into how the crew could have survived. Below are excerpts from the report.

Each member of Ouzos crew had a fully functioning lifejacket. However, none had lights fitted to them. Had the crew of Ouzo had lights fitted to their lifejackets it is possible that one of the many craft that passed through the area on the night of the accident might have seen the lights and raised the alarm.

The report further concludes that simply fitting crotch straps to the lifejackets, which are normally sold as a cheap optional extra, would have enabled them to have stayed in the correct donning position, irrespective of how tight they had been fitted. Had crotch straps been fitted to their lifejackets, it is possible that all three crew would have survived for longer than 12 hours.

Conclusion; Just wearing a lifejacket is not the end. The extras will make a difference. Items like crotch or leg straps stop the life jacket riding up and therefore keep your chin above the water. A spray hood will keep your air way clear. A light or strobe and reflective tape, will help you get spotted. A whistle will also help you get attention.

MAIB report

 



Types of auto inflate mechanism

Principally there are two methods, hydrostatic and water soluble. Hydrostatic models are less likely to go off when they get wet. See Hammar video below

Hammer MA 1 video The hammer is a hydrostatic device and only goes of after the device is held under water by 100mm or 4 inches. The inflator is not designed to go ff in waves or spray as seen in the video. The Hammar device is USCG approved. Cost of re arm kit around $75.

The Halkey Roberts  auto inflator device is water activated by a water soluble powder, which dissolves when wet triggering the device. Cost of re arm kit can be under $20.

Manufacturers like Mustang have models with either the Hammer (MD3183 & MD3184) or Halkey Roberts trigger MD3083 & MD3084.

Service; To maintain the inflation device always have a full cylinder and all status indicators on the inflator must be green

Status Indicators. There are 3 categories of status indicators.

  • 1F is used on automatic inflators and has a "single point" which when green indicates

  • 3F is for manual inflators only

  • 6F is for automatic inflators and has a "two point" status indicator one for the capsule and one for cartridge.

Manual backup;

When you inflate a manual PFD by pulling the tab hanging from the PFD, your pull causes a small pin to pierce the CO2 cylinder that fills the inflatable bladder to capacity.

Oral tubes, are simple valves, which can be inflated by the wearer.

 


Keep your chin above the water

How much buoyancy do you need.

34lbs, (150N) is regarded as the minimum required to turn an unconscious person on their back and head up.

  Buoyancy   Example
   275N=63lbs Commercial auto inflate for workers wearing heavy clothing ISP Challenger
  150N=34lbs The most popular size Spinlock Deckvest & Mustang
  100N=22lbs Coastal good for warm climates Coastal West Marine

 

This distance from the water to your mouth is called freeboard. If knocked unconscious in the water, the added freeboard offered by Type I PFDs may save your life by keeping your airway unobstructed.

Type II and Type III PFDs lack the flotation and righting force to keep wearers face up with an unobstructed airway.

USCG approved Type III inflatables have to average 3" of freeboard and Type II must average 3.75".


Airline carry on regulations

There are two issues; one getting through security (see TSA rules) and then getting on the plane. For the TSA read and copy the regulations, and for the airline call ahead to check their policy.

TSA carry on regulations use this link & scroll down to;

Disabling Chemicals & Other Dangerous Items Carry-on Checked
Small compressed gas cartridges
(Up to 2 in life vests and 2 spares. The spares must accompany the life vests and presented as one unit)
Yes Yes

Carry a copy of the regulations when you fly or check with the airline. These regulations do change.

 

UCSG  regs re auto inflate

USCG rules an auto inflate can be a type II, III or a type V. Type V is the default. Type V will not count in your (1 lifejacket per person) a type III will.

Non USCG inflatables

Other regulators governing life preservers are SOLAS (MCA save out lives at sea), and CE the European governing body.

European lifejackets like spinlock do not have USCG certification. This does not means its a bad lifejacket. In fact the Spinlock is a great lifejacket and has many options that make it better than many US lifejackets.

If you have a Spinlock or other type that does not have USCG approval, its fine for the wearer, but does not count toward the 1 lifejacket per person.


Lifejacket procedures/maintenance

  • Make sure you have a lifejackets that fits

  • know where the lifejackets are stowed, and try one on, maybe even mark it.

  • Owners have One lifejacket per person, but what about sizes.

  • Make sure you have the proper sizes for all.

  • Children and non swimmers need to wear at all times.

  • Clean and dry

  • For washing disarm auto inflate by unscrewing arming head

  • Check lifejackets once a year. Check for UV damage, rotting webbing or fabric

  • For auto inflates, Check gas cylinders, (green)

  • Arming devices need inspection windows

  • Check for leaks, inflate with oral tube for 24hrs


Conclusion

Personal Flotation Device Manufacturers Association This resource will help you with all sorts of questions about PFDs.

Extras count; have a light, spray hood, crotch strap, grab handle, SOLAS reflective tapes, integral harness,

Throwable Flotation devices This article look at throwable flotation USCG type IV.

What drives you when kitting out your boat with safety gear. Are you just worried about satisfying USCG regulations. Or are you interested in the best kit for the safety of your crew and guests. The other organization that regulates pfd is the ORC. The offshore Racing Council have their own European rules and are unlike the USCG.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Home | Newsletters | About | FAQ | Contact Us | Site Map